Drug Tests Show Pain Patients on Opioids Less Likely to Use Illicit Drugs

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

In an effort to reduce soaring rates of drug abuse and overdoses, many physicians have taken their pain patients off opioids and switched them to “safer” non-opioid drugs like pregabalin, gabapentin and duloxetine. Others have encouraged their patients to try non-pharmacological treatments, such as acupuncture, massage and meditation.

That strategy may be backfiring, according to a large new study by Millennium Health, which found that pain patients prescribed opioids are significantly less likely to use illicit drugs than pain patients not getting opioids.

The drug testing firm analyzed urine drug samples from 2019 to 2021 for nearly 55,000 patients being treated by U.S. pain management specialists. About 80% of the patients were prescribed an opioid like oxycodone or hydrocodone, while the other 20% were not prescribed opioids.

Millennium researchers say detectable levels of illicit fentanyl, heroin, methamphetamine and cocaine were far more likely to be found in the urine of non-opioid patients than those who were prescribed opioids. For example, illicit fentanyl was detected in 2.21% of the patients not getting an opioid, compared to 1.169% of those who were. The findings were similar for heroin, methamphetamine and cocaine.

“In all cases, we found that the population that was not prescribed an opioid was significantly more likely to be positive for an illicit drug than those patients who were prescribed opioids,” said lead author Penn Whitley, Director of Bioinformatics at Millennium. “(There was) a 40 to 60 percent increase in the likelihood of being positive if you were not prescribed an opioid.”

Illicit Drug Use By Pain Patients

MILLENNIUM HEALTH

What do the findings mean? Are pain patients getting ineffective non-opioid therapies so desperate for relief that they’re turning to illicit drugs? That’s possible, but the study doesn’t address that specifically.

Another possibility is that patients on opioids are simply being more cautious and careful about their drug use. Opioid prescribing in the U.S. has fallen by 48% over the past five years, with many patients being forcibly tapered or abandoned by doctors who feel pressured to reduce their prescribing.  

“Unfortunately, a lot of people with chronic pain have learned that it’s a bit tenuous, that their doctors are feeling pressure, and if they want to maintain their access (to opioids), they need their PDMP (Prescription Drug Monitoring Program) and their drug tests to look the way they need to look, so their doctor can feel comfortable continuing to prescribe,” said co-author Steven Passik, PhD, VP of Scientific Affairs and Head of Clinical Data Programs at Millennium. “I do think they realize that they’re on a treatment and that access to it is not guaranteed.”   

Preliminary findings from the study were released today at PainWeek, an annual conference for pain management providers. The findings mirror those from another Millennium study earlier this year, which found that pain patients have lower rates of illicit drug use than patients being treated by other providers.     

“If your main way of protecting people in pain from getting involved in substance abuse is to limit their access to opioids, there’s at least a hint here that’s not the right approach,” Passik told PNN. “It’s not a definitive statement by any stretch of the imagination, but it’s an approach to patient safety that leaves a bit to be desired.”  

Another recent study at the University of Texas also found that restricting access to opioids is “not a panacea” and may even lead to more overdoses.  Researchers found that in states that mandated PDMP use, opioid prescribing decreased as intended, but heroin overdose deaths rose 50 percent.

“Past research has shown that when facing restricted access to addictive substances, individuals simply seek out alternatives rather than limiting consumption,” said lead author Tongil Kim, PhD, an assistant professor of marketing at University of Texas at Dallas. “In our case, we measured overdose deaths as a proxy and found a substantial increase, suggesting that the policy unintentionally spurred greater substitution.”

Abuse of Rx Opioid Painkillers Unchanged During Pandemic

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

An alarming spike in U.S. overdose deaths during the COVID-19 pandemic does not appear to be fueled by increased abuse of opioid painkillers, according to a new nationwide analysis of urine drug tests.

The Drug Enforcement Administration approved an exemption last year allowing patients to connect with doctors via telehealth – without a physical examination -- to get prescriptions for opioids and other controlled substances. While the relaxed rules made it easier for patients to get pain medication during the pandemic, they have not resulted in more diversion or abuse of oxycodone and hydrocodone, according to the Millennium Health Signals Report. Urine positivity rates for the two opioids remained flat during 2020.

“Despite the hardships faced during the pandemic, it is encouraging to see that positivity rates for non-prescribed use of hydrocodone and oxycodone have not changed,” said Michael Parr, MD, an addiction treatment specialist and consultant to Millennium.

“Patients requiring opioids for the treatment of pain have faced difficulty obtaining medications, as well as stigma, before the pandemic. Perhaps this data will reassure clinicians who have taken additional steps to safely prescribe these medications during the pandemic.”

There was an uptick in positivity rates for non-prescribed tramadol, a weaker opioid, particularly in Ohio, Tennessee and Kentucky. Millennium said there were more cases of people with substance use disorders using tramadol as their “drug of preference.”

Millennium researchers also found that positivity rates for non-prescribed gabapentin (Neurontin) showed little change in 2020 – but they remain at levels nearly three times higher than positivity rates for oxycodone, hydrocodone and tramadol. The abuse of non-prescribed gabapentin did rise significantly in Ohio and Virginia.

POSITIVITY RATES FOR NON-PRESCRIBED PAIN MEDICATIONS

SOURCE: MILLENNIUM HEALTH

SOURCE: MILLENNIUM HEALTH

The abuse of gabapentin has been going on for years, but with little public attention. Gabapentin is a non-opioid nerve medication increasingly prescribed for pain, despite the fact many patients say it doesn’t help and has too many side effects. Drug abusers, however, have found that gabapentin can heighten the effect of heroin and other street drugs.

While positivity rates for non-prescribed pain medication were mostly unchanged during the pandemic, they soared for illicit fentanyl and methamphetamine, increasing 78% and 29%, respectively.

After initially increasing in the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis, Millennium found that positivity rates for cocaine and heroin soon returned to pre-pandemic levels.

Another encouraging sign is that positivity rates for carfentanil, a deadly fentanyl analogue, have flatlined to nearly zero. It is unclear why carfentanil abuse has fallen so sharply, but Millennium said it may be because the pandemic has disrupted manufacturing and supply routes from China.     

Fentanyl and Heroin Use Rise During Pandemic

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

The use of illicit fentanyl and heroin rose dramatically during the first two months of the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a large new study by Quest Diagnostics. Misuse of hydrocodone, morphine and some other opioid medications also increased.

The study adds to growing signs that Americans are turning to potent illicit drugs to cope with the stress and economic disruption caused by the pandemic.

“It’s the social isolation, the depression, the anxiety, stress, job loss, the loss of health insurance and the election. All these things that add stress to our lives are driving people to increase use of alcohol at home and, in the case of this study, drug misuse,” said co-author Harvey Kaufman, MD, Senior Medical Director for Quest Diagnostics. 

Kaufman and his colleagues analyzed data from over 872,000 urine drug tests, comparing samples taken before the pandemic to those taken from March 15 to May 14, 2020. The urine samples came largely from people undergoing substance abuse treatment or were prescribed opioids and other controlled substances, and are not representative of the population at large.

Interestingly, while the rate of drug misuse remained largely the same before and during the pandemic – about 49 percent – there were notable shifts in the type of drugs being misused.

Drug positivity rates increased by 44% for heroin and 35% for non-prescribed fentanyl, a synthetic opioid that is 50 to 100 times more potent than morphine. Positivity rates for non-prescribed opiate medication (hydrocodone, hydromorphone, codeine and morphine) rose by 10 percent. There were no significant changes in the misuse of oxycodone and tramadol. 

Fentanyl was frequently found in urine samples that tested positive for amphetamines (89%), benzodiazepines (48%), cocaine (34%), and opiates (39%). The abuse of multiple substances in combination with fentanyl has been a growing problem for years, but Quest researchers were surprised by how much it has accelerated.

“It’s shocking that something could move that quickly. It’s been well underway for half a dozen years, but the pandemic supercharged it,” Kaufman told PNN.

Gabapentin Misuse

One surprising detail in the Quest study is that the nerve drug gabapentin (Neurontin) is being misused more often than any other prescription drug. Non-prescribed gabapentin was found in nearly 11% of urine samples — second only to marijuana — in the first two months of the pandemic. While that’s down from pre-pandemic levels, it adds to a growing body of evidence that gabapentin is being overprescribed and abused.

POSITIVITY RATES FOR NON-PRESCRIBED DRUGS (MARCH-MAY 2020)

SOURCE: QUEST DIAGNOSTICS

Gabapentin was originally developed as an anti-convulsant, but it has been repurposed to treat chronic pain and is often prescribed off-label as an alternative to opioids. When taken as prescribed, there is little potential for gabapentin to be misused. However, when taken with muscle relaxants, opioids or anxiety medications, gabapentin can produce a feeling of euphoria or high.

A likely factor in the decline in gabapentin misuse during the pandemic is a drop in physician visits. Fewer visits mean fewer prescriptions, and gabapentin may have become less available for diversion.

Just as stay-at-home orders forced many patients to cancel or postpone healthcare appointments, it also led a significant decline in drug testing. Orders for lab tests by Quest dropped by as much as 70% in the first few weeks of the pandemic. They have since rebounded, but are still well below pre-pandemic levels.

“COVID-19 interrupted non-essential patient care, but it hasn’t stopped drug misuse,” co-author Jeffrey Gudin, MD, Senior Medical Advisor to Quest, said in a statement. “Given the psychological, social, and financial impacts of the COVID-19 crisis, more efforts are needed to ensure that patients are taking medications as prescribed. While the nation focuses on the pandemic, we must not lose sight of the ongoing drug misuse epidemic, which continues to kill upwards of 70,000 Americans each year.” 

After briefly declining in 2018, drug overdoses began rising again in 2019. According to one preliminary study, drug overdoses are up about 17 percent so far this year.

Drug Tests Show Kratom Use Doubled in U.S.

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

Kratom use in the U.S. appears to have doubled in the last two years, according to a large analysis of urine drug tests by Millennium Health. The first of its kind study also found that nearly 1 out of 4 people who tested positive for kratom were abusing opioids, benzodiazepines or other substances.

Kratom is an herbal supplement that millions of Americans use to self-treat their chronic pain, anxiety, depression and addiction. It comes from the leaves of a tree that grows in southeast Asia, where kratom has been used for centuries as a natural stimulant and pain reliever.

Millennium Health analyzed over 400,000 urine samples collected from 2017 to 2019, using liquid chromatography mass spectrometry to test for mitragynine and 7-hydroxymitragynine, two alkaloids that are the active ingredients in kratom.

The drug tests were ordered for patients by doctors in primary care, pain management and addiction treatment. As a result, the findings may not represent the typical kratom user.

Positivity rates for kratom doubled over the study period, rising from 0.9% in January 2017 to 1.8% in November 2019. Use of kratom rose in every section of the country, with the highest positivity rates reported in Idaho (4.2%), Montana (2.9%), Colorado (2.3%), Utah (2.3%) and Florida (2.1%).

The American Kratom Association generously estimates that over 15 million Americans use kratom. As interest in the herbal supplement has grown, so have the number of doctors ordering drug tests to see if their patients are using it.

“There are clinicians out there, that are caring for these type patients, that are likely to have kratom users in their population. It’s a small number, about 2 percent or so, but it’s likely increasing,” says Eric Dawson, PharmD, Vice-President of Clinical Affairs for Millennium.

One of the more surprising aspects of the study was how many kratom users were abusing other substances. For urine samples testing positive for kratom, nearly 25% were also found to be positive for non-prescribed opioids and 22% tested positive for non-prescribed benzodiazepines, an anti-anxiety drug.

Methamphetamine, fentanyl, cocaine and heroin were also more likely to be detected in positive samples for kratom versus those that tested negative.

SOURCE: MILLENNIUM HEALTH

Kratom use has been growing in the U.S. as people seek alternatives to opioid pain relievers and other pharmaceutical drugs. Many also use kratom to self-treat alcoholism or opioid addiction.

“You have these two camps, very pro-kratom and very anti-kratom. We purposely tried not to fall into either one and simply answer the questions we were being asked and see what the data is,” Dawson told PNN. “I’m very interested to see what happens to kratom moving forward in the next few years because the benefits are very compelling, but conversely so are the negatives. It’s quite an interesting compound for sure.”  

Most federal agencies take a dim view of kratom. The FDA says kratom is addictive, has opioid-like qualities, and should not be used for any medical condition. The CDC has linked kratom to dozens of fatal overdoses -- although multiple substances were involved in nearly all of those deaths.

Although kratom remains legal at the federal level, several states have banned kratom and some counties and cities have enacted local ordinances prohibiting sales.

A recent study funded by the National Institute on Drug Abuse concluded that kratom is an effective treatment for pain, helps users reduce their use of opioids, and is “relatively safe” to use.

There’s More Concern About Animals Suffering Than People

By Debbie Westerman, Guest Columnist

I have Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, as well four herniated discs in my lower back. Because of the “opioid crisis,” I was taken off the only medication that ever helped: fentanyl.

I see a reputable doctor and he is very sympathetic. But as he put it, doctors are no longer just being sued, they are being threatened with jail time.

In addition to my pain and fear, I felt so sorry for him. We’ve tried everything: nerve blocks, injections and I have two spinal cord stimulators.

I was weaned off the fentanyl and only have hydrocodone that I take for breakthrough pain. 

I’ve done everything I’m supposed to. I have an appointment with my doctor every 28 days, along with random drug tests to make sure I’m only taking what he’s prescribing.

My insurance doesn’t pay for the random drug tests. I have to pay $150 each time. I don’t abuse my meds. All of my doctors know what I’m taking. I don’t get any type of pain meds from anyone except my pain management doctor.

DEBBIE WESTERMAN

I have to go to work every day. I’m single and have to take care of myself. I use a walker to get around. It’s been months since I have slept more than 2 to 4 hours a night. I’m constantly turning over, putting the pillow under my legs or between my legs, and the rest of the night I’m in and out of bed trying to walk because the pain is so bad.

What really gets me is that if I were an animal and suffering this bad with this much pain, I would be humanely put down. As a society we’ve become more concerned about our animals than we are about people who are suffering unspeakable, unexplainable amounts of pain.

I’ve never wished my pain on anyone. But I really wish that there was some way that these people who think they know what’s best for me could spend 6 hours in my shoes. I guarantee they would be screaming a different tune.

Debbie Westerman lives in Texas.

Pain News Network invites other readers to share their stories with us. Send them to editor@painnewsnetwork.org. 

The information in this column is for informational purposes only and represents the author’s opinions alone. It does not inherently express or reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of Pain News Network.