FDA Uncovers Errors in Opioid Database
/By Pat Anson, Editor
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has identified potentially serious errors in a database of opioid sales maintained by IQVIA - a private company that provides data to the federal government on the volume of drugs sold by manufacturers and wholesalers to pharmacies and hospitals.
The FDA said the errors “raise serious questions” about the reliability of IQVIA’s database, which is used by the Drug Enforcement Administration to set opioid production quotas for drug makers. In the last two years, the DEA has reduced opioid production quotas by as much as 45 percent, claiming there was less demand for opioids and that the market was oversupplied with them.
“When we discover irregularities or inconsistencies in the data we use, we take such deficiencies very seriously,” the FDA said in a statement. "The FDA uses these data to assist the DEA in determining the medical and research needs for Schedule I and II controlled substances in the U.S. for the upcoming year."
The FDA believes the error was caused when IQVIA incorrectly converted into kilograms the amount of prescription fentanyl contained in transdermal skin patches and other fentanyl products. As a result, FDA researchers believe the company overestimated the amount of fentanyl sold in the U.S. in the last five years by over 20 percent.
“This error caused IQVIA to overestimate the total amount of fentanyl distributed into the marketplace,” the FDA said. “As a result of this work, we identified additional data quality issues related to several other controlled substances with similar weight-based conversion factors, including oxymorphone and hydrocodone. These additional errors raise serious concerns about systemic issues with IQVIA’s data and quality control procedures.”
Fentanyl is a potent synthetic opioid that is used to treat severe chronic pain and acute pain in patients recovering from surgery and trauma. There is currently a nationwide shortage of intravenous fentanyl and other opioids that has forced some hospitals to postpone surgeries or use other pain medications that are less effective.
FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, MD, called on IQVIA to immediately hire an independent, third party auditor to conduct a review of its database. Gottlieb said he would brief members of Congress about the data issues and their potential impact on public health.
IQVIA was formed in 2016 after the merger of IMS Health and Quintiles, two prominent healthcare research firms. The company released a statement saying it identified the problems in its opioid database last month and notified customers.
“Recently, we made a correction to a kilogram conversion measurement in the United States IQVIA National Sales Perspective (NSP) market research service affecting reported measurements for transdermal patches in the opioid market,” the company said. “IQVIA’s internal processes had already identified the measurement conversion issue prior to the FDA’s notification. We notified our clients about this measurement conversion issue in April of this year. Ongoing steps have been undertaken to correct this measurement conversion issue.
“We stand behind our data methodologies. We value our long-standing relationship with the FDA. We take the FDA’s concerns seriously and will continue working with the FDA to resolve these concerns to its satisfaction.”
If confirmed, the database errors would be the second admission by federal agencies this year that their analysis of opioid prescriptions relied on faulty data. In March, four researchers in the CDC’s ironically named Division of Unintentional Injury Prevention acknowledged that many overdoses involving illicit fentanyl and other synthetic black market opioids were erroneously counted as prescription drug deaths.
