How Realistic Is a Possible Treatment for Hypermobile EDS?

By Crystal Lindell, PNN Columnist

Ever since I was diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hEDS) back in 2018, I’ve spent countless hours contemplating what my life would be like if there was an effective treatment.

Last week, Tulane University School of Medicine pushed that question to the forefront. They announced that they may have found a potential cause of hEDS and hypermobility in general. They also theorized a potential treatment.

Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS) creates fragile connective tissue, which can cause a range of other symptoms including joint pain, digestive trouble, migraines and more.  

Tulane researchers proposed that a variation of the MTHFR gene that causes a deficiency of folate – the natural form of vitamin B9 – could hold the key to hypermobility and a range of connective tissue disorders such as EDS. As for treatment, they hypothesized that methylated folate — which is folate that is already processed — could be a possible treatment for the myofascial pain that’s common for hypermobile patients. They published these preliminary findings in the journal Heliyon.

First, it should be noted that none of this was based on a clinical study of patients. Rather, it’s a proposal that they believe should be researched further. As such, there’s been some valid criticism of Tulane’s announcement from the EDS community. Was it premature? Will any of this hold up in a peer-reviewed study? Or are they just giving false hope to the thousands of EDS patients desperate for some good news?

As an EDS patient myself, I understand those concerns and I very much sympathize with them. Many of us have spent too much time being dismissed by doctors, and too much money on treatments that don’t end up working.

Unfortunately, I think we’re going to have to live in the uncertainty right now. We won’t know if this is a viable option until we get a peer-reviewed study. But I am glad that they are looking into this and sharing these types of updates as the research progresses. I’d rather be informed along the way than only be told at the end of the process.

What Would a Treatment Mean for Patients?

What if their theory is correct though? Is that a good thing? I have to confess, my feelings about it are complicated.

The thing about EDS is that it’s different for everyone. As it stands, most doctors treat the symptoms, which, as mentioned above, vary widely. For me, the most debilitating one is intercostal neuralgia — which is not a type of myofascial pain. As such, it seems unlikely that methylated folate would do much to treat it.

But hey, maybe methylated folate is more of a preventative treatment? That alone would be an incredible advancement for hEDS patients.

The question is, would this treatment impact anything else? Do they know if it would only address myofascial pain? Or could it also help with other symptoms? And would that even be a good thing if it did?

EDS touches every aspect of my body and even most aspects of my personality. There’s the velvety skin everyone comments on when they shake my hand. And the constant comments about how I look for my age, which also seems to be related to how EDS impacts my skin. Would methylated folate treatment change that at all? How so? And what would I end up looking like?

The most well-known EDS symptom is probably loose joints, which means they easily overextend. For me, that’s meant a lifetime of sprained ankles and joint pain. But again, what happens if methylated folate changes that? My joints may be loose, but they’re the only ones I’ve ever known. Would stiffening them up actually help me at this point? Or would I have to re-learn how to move my own body?

What about my mind? EDS patients have higher than average rates of neurodivergence like autism and ADHD. They also have higher rates of mental health issues like depression and anxiety. Could this treatment change our brains too? Or, if not, what if they eventually find a treatment that does? Would it alter aspects of people’s personalities?

There’s also the more logistical issue of EDS as a name at all. According to the National Library of Medicine, a syndrome refers to a group of symptoms and physical findings without a direct cause. Once a cause is found, the symptoms are typically renamed as a “disease.” So, if the researchers at Tulane did find a cause, what do we have? Ehlers-Danlos disease? EDD?

One thing we do know is that EDS and hypermobility cause immeasurable pain and suffering for a lot of people, so we do need more research into potential treatments. Time will tell if folate treatment proves effective or not, but either way, I hope that there are a lot more potential treatments coming.

Crystal Lindell is a freelance writer who lives in Illinois. After five years of unexplained rib pain, Crystal was finally diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. She and her fiancé have 3 cats: Princess Dee, Basil, and Goose. She enjoys the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Taylor Swift Easter eggs, and playing the daily word game Semantle. 

Researchers Find Possible Cause of Hypermobile EDS

By Crystal Lindell, PNN Columnist

Do we finally have a genetic link for hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome?

Researchers at Tulane University School of Medicine think so – and it could even point to an effective treatment that’s already available.

A variation of the MTHFR gene that causes a deficiency of folate – the natural form of vitamin B9 – could hold the key to hypermobility and a range of associated connective tissue disorders such as Ehlers-Danlos (EDS), according to preliminary findings published in the journal Heliyon.

“You’ve got millions of people that likely have this, and until now, there’s been no known cause we’ve known to treat,” said Gregory Bix, MD, director of the Tulane University Clinical Neuroscience Research Center. “It’s a big deal.”

People with the genetic variant can’t metabolize folate, which causes unmetabolized folate to accumulate in the bloodstream. The resulting folate deficiency in other parts of the body prevents key proteins from binding collagen to the extracellular matrix, which plays an important role in cell growth. This leads to more elastic connective tissue, hypermobility, and a potential cascade of associated conditions, researchers said.

The discovery could help doctors more accurately diagnose hypermobility and hypermobile EDS by looking for elevated folate levels in blood tests and the MTHFR genetic variant.

“Hypermobility is widespread and unfortunately under-recognized,” said Jacques Courseault, MD, medical director of the Tulane Fascia Institute and Treatment Center. “I’m excited about being able to treat the masses where people aren’t going their whole lives being frustrated and not getting the treatment they need."

Doctors discovered the connection between folate deficiency and the MTHFR gene by working with patients at Tulane’s Hypermobility and Ehlers-Danlos Clinic, the only clinic in the U.S. that focuses on fascia disorders. Blood tests of hypermobile patients revealed elevated levels of unmetabolized folate. Subsequent tests showed that most of those with elevated folate serum levels had the MTHFR genetic variant.

The good news is a treatment already exists. Methylated folate – folate that is already processed – is FDA-approved and widely available.

“It’s an innocuous treatment,” Bix said. “It’s not dangerous, and it’s a vitamin that can improve people’s lives. That’s the biggest thing: We know what’s going on here, and we can treat it.”

“We’ve discovered something in medicine that can help, not a small group of people, but potentially many across the world.”

— Dr. Jacques Courseault

Though more studies and clinical testing needs to be done, researchers say patients who have been treated with folate have shown improvement: less pain, less brain fog, fewer allergies and improved gastrointestinal function.

“We’ve discovered something in medicine that can help, not a small group of people, but potentially many across the world,” Courseault said. “This is real, it’s been vetted out well and clinically we’re noticing a difference.”

What Is Hypermobile EDS?

For those with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), the same conditions that create fragile connective tissue can cause a range of other symptoms that, on the surface, can seem unrelated: joint pain, chronic fatigue, thin tooth enamel, dizziness, digestive trouble and migraines, as well as psychiatric disorders such as anxiety and depression. Women with hypermobile EDS may also be at increased risk for endometriosis or uterine fibroids.

For years, researchers have struggled to find the cause of hypermobility and hypermobile EDS. Of the 13 subtypes of EDS, hypermobile EDS comprises more than 90 percent of cases. But until this study, hypermobile EDS was the only subtype without a known genetic correlate. As a result, symptoms have often been treated individually, without EDS being recognized as the likely cause.

Until now, hypermobility could only be diagnosed by the Beighton score, a somewhat controversial physical exam that involves measuring the bend of the spine, fingers and limbs. There has also been a historic lack of acceptance of hypermobility as a disorder that requires specialized treatment.

Many patients with hypermobile EDS never get a proper diagnosis. As a result, the number of people with hypermobility is unclear, though it could comprise more than half the world’s population.

“Hypermobility is not rare,” Courseault said. “Hypermobility is like a Ferrari that requires a lot of maintenance and the best synthetic oil. After knowing a patient's name and date of birth, I think it's prudent for clinicians to know which of these body types they have.”

Crystal Lindell is a freelance writer who lives in Illinois. After five years of unexplained rib pain, Crystal was finally diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. She and her fiancé have 3 cats: Princess Dee, Basil, and Goose. She enjoys the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Taylor Swift Easter eggs, and playing the daily word game Semantle. 

Hypermobility Linked to Depression and Anxiety at Young Age

By Madora Pennington, PNN Columnist

The teenage years are difficult for almost everyone, but even more so for teens with hypermobile joints, a condition known as hypermobility. Their joints have an excess range of motion, and some can literally bend their arms, legs and fingers backward.

Jess — who asked that we not use her last name — had always noticed she was extremely flexible. By the time she was a teenager, Jess had crushing fatigue and anxiety. She obsessed over her grades like a perfectionist and developed an eating disorder. Her terrible anxiety caused her to self-medicate, as she did all she could to keep up with her peers.

Eventually, it all became too much. Jess had to leave high school and finish her degree through proficiency testing. Not until age 19 was she finally diagnosed with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), a disease that weakens connective tissue in the joints and causes hypermobility.

Hypermobility in early life is normal. All babies and children are highly flexible, which most eventually outgrow. But for some children, hypermobility is permanent. Excessively loose joints are a feature common to many inherited disorders like EDS, wherein the body cannot make connective tissue that is stable and strong. In essence, the "glue" holding their bodies together is flawed and weak.

Extremely flexible people like Jess may be seen by their peers as having interesting or cool skills, like doing contortionist tricks or excelling in yoga. But hypermobility is a severe health problem that can lead to mental health issues.

"Hypermobility affects one in four people in the UK. Like other musculoskeletal conditions, it can have a profound and far-reaching impact on life, causing daily pain, fatigue and often disrupted sleep," says Dr. Neha Issar-Brown, Director of Research and Health Intelligence at the UK-based charity Versus Arthritis. "Previous studies in adults have shown that you are more likely to suffer from anxiety if you have hypermobility, and that the daily toll of painful symptoms can lead to depression.”

A new study in BMJ Open found a similar link in adolescents. To see if there is an association between hypermobility, anxiety and depression in late adolescence, researchers at Brighton and Sussex Medical School evaluated over 14,000 teens with joint hypermobility.

At age 14, their hypermobility was scored, which is done by measuring the degree to which various joints hyperextend or bend past the point where they should. Then, at age 18, the participants answered surveys about depression and anxiety. Pain, a common complication of hypermobility, was also taken into account. The participants' heart rates were also studied.

"Many psychiatric problems, including depression and anxiety, start before the age of 25. It is therefore important to identify the factors that may increase the risk for these disorders. Being aware of the link between hypermobility and depression and anxiety means that we can work on developing appropriate and effective treatments," said lead author Dr. Jessica Eccles, Department of Neuroscience, Brighton and Sussex Medical School.

Eccles and her colleagues found that young people with joint hypermobility were more likely to have depression and anxiety, and their psychiatric symptoms were also more severe. Joint hypermobility was more common in females than males, but it was only among males that hypermobility increased the risk for depression.

"This study has highlighted the need for more targeted and bespoke support for hypermobile teenagers, particularly girls," says Lea Milligan, CEO of the UK-based advocacy organization MK Mental Health Research. "The findings don't just show the need for support for this group of individuals, but also demonstrate the importance of research that takes a whole mind, body brain approach to health and uses longitudinal studies to improve our understanding of which demographics are at higher risk of depression and anxiety.”

Why hypermobile people suffer from more psychopathologies may be due to a dysregulation of the nervous system called dysautonomia, which is very common among those with loose joints. Their poorly regulated nervous systems cause a rapid increase in heart rate when they rise to stand, when it should remain constant. This inability of the body to maintain a smooth and consistent heart rate when posture changes has also been associated with anxiety.

Rapid heart rates and poor cardiovascular regulation also occur when someone has anxiety and depression. The higher a person's resting heart rate, the more psychological symptoms tend to follow. Those with depression tend to have different skin temperatures, breathing rates, and a lower variability in heart rate.

Complaints from UK parents with hypermobile children motivated this study. They encountered healthcare providers that were ignorant of the complications and challenges of hypermobility and dismissed their concerns. More awareness and education are needed to help these families, and this study is a step in that direction.

Madora Pennington is the author of the blog LessFlexible.com about her life with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. She graduated from UC Berkeley with minors in Journalism and Disability Studies. 

My Wife Had Ehlers-Danlos and Didn’t Know It

By John Ferman, Guest Columnist

We were married for 41 years.  You’d think after all of that time you would know everything there was to know about a person.

I knew Carol as a loving wife who would do anything she could for the kids and the family. She was a social worker and very concerned about the comfort of others. She didn’t complain and didn’t want others to worry about her.

Carol’s symptoms started shortly after we were married in 1967.  Carol was very energetic, had just graduated with a master’s degree in guidance and counseling, and was anxious to start her new career. She also was somewhat of a “perfectionist” who wanted to keep the house clean and organized, but started to develop some pains as a result.

I remember attending Lamaze classes in 1969, when she was pregnant with our first daughter. The instructor commented on how “flexible” Carol seemed to be during the exercises. Our first daughter Deborah was 4 weeks premature and the second daughter Deanna was 7 weeks premature. We joked that if she got pregnant again we would have to carry around a basket to be ready for the next one.

CAROL FERMAN

Carol’s joint pain got more severe in the 1980’s. She was the first director of a new crisis hotline in the Cleveland, Ohio area and was working unusually long hours.  With all of the mental and physical stresses she was going to a chiropractor monthly and then weekly.  She was also getting massages on a regular basis.

Initially, Carol’s neck, back and shoulders were the major issues. The doctors did not seem to understand her pain and could only recommend ointments and pain medication.  It did not seem to help. She was diagnosed with Thoracic Outlet Syndrome, TMJ and maybe fibromyalgia, but they were not sure. 

I was taking over the household tasks of cleaning, doing the dishes and the laundry.  Some family members commented that they thought Carol “looked perfectly okay” but was weak, lazy and taking advantage of my help. I knew there was a problem with her pain but I did not know what it was or what else to do to help.  

In addition, Carol had severe allergies, IBS symptoms and an extremely sensitive stomach, so she avoided certain foods, spices, and medications. Her allergies often limited where we went for social activities and even restricted purchasing certain items if they had chemical smells, dust, or cigarette odors.

She had flat feet and was prescribed orthotics. Her feet always hurt and finding comfortable shoes was challenging.  She had very sensitive hearing and was a very light sleeper. The slightest noise would wake her.  Pain and disturbed sleep meant she always woke up exhausted!

Carol would describe affected parts of her body as shifted, twisted, crooked, and her favorite word "discombobulated" (meaning everything was zig-zag and out-of-whack). Her pain was achy and throbbing, and she also had episodes of radiating pain, stabbing, pinched nerves and numbness. She would say things like, "I will hurt myself if I reach or stretch for that item, or if I bend that way or if I twist my body."

She had a lot of extra pain if she tried to carry something that was awkward or too heavy. My daughters could carry heavier items than my wife, and the kids and I did a lot of the fetching, carrying and cleaning for her. I made most of the meals and got the kids off to school.

As a result of her non-restorative sleep and pain, Carol was often in bed until the kids got off the bus from school. The girls would run upstairs to the bedroom, eager to spend some quality time with mom, as she was getting out of bed in the middle of the day. The girls remember it as a special time. Moments like these with her girls gave her some comfort and support, but the girls were sometimes embarrassed. They could not tell anyone that their mother was in bed all day.

Carol’s muscles were always tight, and she often described her pain as if "one part of her body was pulling at another.” The only exercise she could tolerate was very slow walking. She loved walking at sunset in the park.

She had pain driving a car and searched extensively to find the most comfortable car so she could remain independent. It was very stressful for her to be a passenger in a car. She would try to brace herself for the starts, stops, bumps, and turns.  If I was driving, she would request alternate routes for straighter roads. We would sometimes go 3 or 4 miles out of our way to find a smooth straight road for her to travel on.

We didn’t know at the time that these were telltale symptoms of Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS).

Carol was very discouraged that the doctors did not believe her and she stopped telling them about her pain because the tests came back “normal” and there was no treatment or even a reason for her pain. They just told her she was overly-sensitive, exaggerating, or “it’s all in your head.” 

It really bothered her that her medical records said all those bad things about her "mental state.”  She tried at times, in vain, to get the records changed. She knew that when she was depressed, it was due to fatigue, lack of sleep and pain. Not because she was making up things to be sad about.

She could only sustain working for a few more years part time, and then it got to be too much for her physically.

We continued to play out that very difficult lifestyle until Carol was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2002. The continuing pains, surgeries and chemotherapy took their toll on her and she had a major struggle with clinical depression.  She was on so many medications that they masked many of the symptoms.

Carol passed away in 2008 of breast cancer as a result of some prescribed medication, the same year my daughter Deanna was diagnosed with EDS.  In her early 20’s, Deanna developed many of the same symptoms and pain as her mom. They often talked about the similarities and offered each other comfort and understanding.

EDS is a genetic defect in collagen protein -- the “glue” that supports and holds the body together. It causes chronic pain, joint hyper-mobility (double-jointedness and fragile joints) and affects multiple other body systems. There is no fix -- no medicine or surgery -- that resolves this condition. However, it is important that EDS be diagnosed and managed, so that symptoms can be controlled and appropriate preventive measures can be taken.

If only someone had told Carol about EDS. It would have saved both mother and daughter much suffering, loneliness and judgment.  I don't have room in this article for all the details about how undiagnosed EDS harmed my wife and daughter's lives.  Just believe me when I say emphatically that if they had known about EDS, their lives would have been dramatically different!

DEANNA HAMM

Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome is not rare. It is rarely diagnosed.  It is estimated that EDS affects more than 1 in 5,000 people worldwide, but only 5% are correctly diagnosed with one of the 6 major forms of EDS.  In the United States alone, 650,000 sufferers go undiagnosed every year due to physician mistakes or lack of knowledge about the condition.

Many afflicted with EDS - and the people who care for them – don’t know where to turn for information, advice and help with issues such as treatments, therapies, practitioners and products to assist in managing the symptoms. The majority of those who are undiagnosed do not know this disorder exists and are left on their own, struggling to find a reason and a name for the pain and suffering they are experiencing. They suffer for many years and die – never knowing why they had the pain.

Tell someone about EDS today and every day. I do! You could improve a life or even save one!

John Ferman and his daughter Deanna Hamm are co–founders of EDS Awareness, a non-profit online resource for the Ehlers Danlos Syndrome community. John is a full time volunteer managing the program. Deanna is a pre-med graduate with Hypermobile EDS. She leads the Cleveland Ohio EDS Support Group.

Pain News Network invites other readers to share their stories with us.  Send them to:  editor@PainNewsNetwork.org. 

The information in this column should not be considered as professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. It is for informational purposes only and represent the author’s opinions alone. It does not inherently express or reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of Pain News Network.