Nearly Half of Adults Think U.S. Healthcare System Is Failing

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

Almost half of American adults (44%) give the U.S. healthcare system poor or failing grades, according to a new Gallup survey that found most respondents concerned about rising medical costs and growing healthcare inequality. Overall, the healthcare system was given a barely passing grade of C-minus.

"After years of higher prices, growing inequities, skipping treatments, getting sicker, or borrowing money to pay medical bills, it's no wonder so many Americans view the health system so poorly," said Timothy Lash, President of West Health, a group of healthcare non-profits that commissioned the survey.

The survey of nearly 5,600 Americans in all 50 states was conducted in June, with a nationally representative sample reflecting racial and ethnic backgrounds.

The worst overall grade on the healthcare report card – a D-minus – was given to the cost of care. One in four adults (26%) did not seek treatment due to cost in the last three months; while one in three (35%) are concerned they will be unable to afford healthcare in the next 12 months.  

Healthcare in America Report Card

source: west health-Gallup

The affordability issue is worse for those living with chronic health conditions. About 1 in 5 skipped care to pay for other household expenses, compared to about one in eight of those without chronic conditions.

“When members of my family have needed surgeries or medications [they] have to really consider how much medical debt they’re willing to go into. Our healthcare system forces us to try and make calculations between financial security and health just because of how expensive things are, and that’s even with health insurance, so I can’t imagine if you didn’t have health insurance how fraught that would be,” said survey participant Stef Schloo, 28, who lives in Pennsylvania

“I am single and so all of that falls down on me. And the only thing that would concern me is if I really developed a major health situation or, God forbid, if I was in a major accident or had to have long-term care, that’s a great concern to me,” said Patricia Slough, 67, who lives in Massachusetts.

Quality of care was the only aspect of the healthcare system that received more positive than negative marks, although it was still only able to earn an overall grade of C-plus. Women were less likely to give good grades for quality than men (38% vs. 57%); and Black and Hispanic Americans were also less likely to give a good grade for quality than the general population (36% each vs. 47%).

“You can have some of the best doctors in the world practicing here. I’m not saying that other countries don’t have great doctors, but I think our healthcare professionals can be second to none depending on where you go in America,” said Andrew Kerner, 30, who lives in North Carolina.

Healthcare Access and Equity

The grades for access to care and equitable care also broke down along racial lines. Two-thirds of Black Americans (66%) and Asian Americans (64%) selected a grade of D or F for health equity, which is the ability of every person to get quality care regardless of race and ethnicity. By comparison, Hispanic Americans (55%) and White Americans (53%) gave a poor or failing grade to equity,

Women, Blacks, Hispanics and Asian Americans were also more critical when it came to access to care. More than 40% in each of these groups gave access D’s and F’s, compared to about a third of White Americans and men.

“For the richest country on earth I think we have the most deplorable healthcare system... due to its inequity, mainly due to the way it all depends on how much money somebody has whether they get good healthcare or not,” said Anne Courtney Davis, 71, who lives in Ohio.

The survey also found that most younger and middle-aged adults are worried that Medicare and Social Security will not be available to them when they become eligible. That sentiment cuts across political lines, with 71% of Democrats, 66% of independents and 62% of Republicans worried or extremely worried about not having access to Medicare. When it comes to Social Security, there is even more agreement — 77% of Democrats, 75% of independents and 73% of Republicans are worried it won’t be there for them when they grow older.

Under an 11-point plan by Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL), chair of the National Republican Senatorial Committee, funding for Social Security, Medicare and other so-called entitlements would have to be put to a vote in Congress every five years.

“When I witness these individuals say that Medicare should be renewed every five years, it kind of makes me nervous [it’s] not going to be there for individuals when we get older,” said Nick Lembo, 27, of Indiana. “That’s startling to me because you should want to take care of those who are older than you because eventually... you’re going to be at that age.”