Pain Patients Worried About CDC Expanding Opioid Guideline
/By Pat Anson, PNN Editor
“These guidelines have been a disaster for people with chronic pain.”
“The guideline is flat out wrong on facts, wrong on science and wrong on medical ethics.”
“The CDC has no qualifications or authority to develop pain management guidelines, especially those pertaining to opioid therapy.”
Those are just a few of the comments we received from nearly 4,200 pain patients and healthcare providers who participated in PNN’s survey on impending changes to the CDC's opioid prescribing guideline.
“It has been misunderstood, misapplied, bastardized and weaponized to use against chronic pain patients,” is how one pain sufferer put it.
People obviously have strong opinions about the CDC guideline. Can it be changed and made more effective? Or should the entire guideline be thrown out?
Nearly 75% of the people we surveyed believe the guideline should be withdrawn or revoked. That’s not likely to happen, however, as the CDC completes a lengthy review and update of the guideline that started two years ago.
If anything, the agency seems intent on expanding the guideline to include specific recommendations for treating short-term acute pain, migraine and possibly other pain conditions such as fibromyalgia.
That’s the route recently taken by two advisory panels in Europe, which released guidelines that are even stricter on the use of opioids than the CDC’s.
WHAT SHOULD BE DONE WITH CDC OPIOID GUIDELINE?
This month the UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence advised doctors not to prescribe opioids or any other pain reliever for fibromyalgia, chronic headache, musculoskeletal pain and other types of “primary chronic pain” for which there is no known cause.
In March, the European Pain Federation (EFIC) released similar guidelines, saying “opioids should not be prescribed for people with chronic primary pain as they do not work for these patients.”
At least two members of Physicians for Responsible Opioid Prescribing (PROP), an anti-opioid activist group, served as consultants to the EFIC in making its recommendation. PROP has long urged the CDC to make a similar statement in its guideline.
“This recommendation should explicitly state that opioids should be avoided for fibromyalgia, chronic headache and chronic low back pain,” PROP’s board wrote in a 2015 letter to the CDC’s Dr. Deborah Dowell, one of the co-authors of the 2016 guideline. “We are suggesting this change because evidence-based reviews and expert consensus have found the long-term use of opioids is likely to be counter-productive for fibromyalgia, chronic headache and chronic axial low back pain.”
PROP didn’t get its explicit statement in 2016, but it may be getting another chance as the CDC revises and possibly expands its guideline.
Little Support for Guideline Expansion
In our survey, patients and providers seem to be wary about expanding the guideline to include treatment recommendations for specific conditions. Only about 40% support guidelines for low back pain, fibromyalgia and short-term acute pain. Many believe the CDC has already gone too far and some wonder where the agency gets the regulatory authority to create guidelines for medical conditions.
“CDC should never have developed and issued opioid prescribing guideline, as such work falls outside CDC's mission and expertise. If guidelines are needed, FDA should write,” one respondent said.
“The CDC guideline would be fine, if if were not being weaponized. There is nothing wrong with having guidelines for non-specialists. However, insurance companies have grabbed hold of it and are now using it to deny coverage of what they think is outside the guidelines,” said another.
“Pain and it’s treatment should have a guideline but with the acknowledgment that its never one size fits all,” a patient wrote. “Some standardized measures are useful to help physicians make decisions in acute, cancer, non-cancer pain, and non-narcotic options should be sought first.”
SHOULD CDC MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR TREATING LOW BACK PAIN, FIBROMYLAGIA AND OTHER PAIN CONDITIONS?
Strong Opposition to 90 MME Limit
If there’s anything that patients and providers want changed, it’s the guideline’s recommended dose limit of 90 MME (morphine milligram equivalent). Although voluntary, the daily dose limit has been rigidly applied by many doctors, pharmacists, insurers and regulators. As a result, patients who’ve taken higher doses of opioids for years — and done it safely — suddenly found themselves being tapered to 90 MME or less.
“My spouse has Ehlers Danlos Syndrome. Her chronic severe pain kept her bedridden for years until a doctor found an opioid regimen that worked. She had her life back and was able to function out of bed. This worked for over 12 years,” one man told us.
“Now, the CDC guidelines have caused local practitioners to require cutting her MME equivalent per day from about 300 to 90. They fear liability. When they discuss tapering and are confronted with the question, ‘But this is a genetic tissue disorder, it is not going to taper away,’ they have nothing to say except to point the finger at the CDC and say they are afraid of being sued. This is going to put her back in bed and, I'm afraid, kill her.”
Asked what changes should be made to the CDC’s recommended dose limit of 90 MME, nearly 87% said there should be no limit on opioid dosages.
“My doctor drastically reduced my medication and I suffer for it. Can hardly walk, can't function like I want to, no one cares as long as its 90 MME. Doesn't matter if I require higher dose and have tolerated it just fine for years,” a patient said.
“I was force tapered in 2016. I've been unable to fill legitimate prescriptions several times and denied meds by my insurance unless I use what they say is equivalent,” a patient told us.
“I was forced tapered from 550mg down to 90mg without my consent,” another patient wrote.
“Pretty much told that I would either take the lower prescribed dose or suck it up without pain relief,” said another.
WHAT CHANGES SHOULD BE MADE TO CDC'S DOSE LIMIT OF 90 MME?
“All of a sudden you can't have your regular prescription. Doesn't matter if it effects my health adversely. Blood pressure through the roof, NEVER had that problem before with it, but keep that 90 MME no matter what. Doctors sympathize but they are too scared to help you,” another patient said. “This rule doesn't help chronic pain patients at all and it doesn't stop overdoses. It needs to change.”
“My physician has been told by the hospital board that they have to reduce the amount of pain medication to ALL patients to an equivalent of 90mg. I have been taken off 70mg of my pain medications that I have taken for over 20 years,” wrote yet another patient.
“The doctor has told me he must continue to taper me more. He knows I am suffering but his hands are tied. The CDC must allow physicians that are experts in the pain management field to treat their patients as individuals. I have a lot more to say but can not type anymore as it causes me great amount of pain to use my hands and fingers.”
We received thousands of comments like these from patients, doctors, caretakers, spouses and loved ones.
One of the more poignant ones came from an intractable pain patient who considers herself lucky to have a doctor who slowly tapered her down to 90 MME. That doctor has now retired. She fears for her future and those of other patients.
“It’s my feeling we’ll look back on all this one day and realize this was in every aspect of the word a genocide; an attack on the weakest of us, the ones who most needed protection, but were mercilessly denied it.”
“I’ve managed to get to 90 MME from a dose much higher, as I was most definitely a high dose patient, but it only happened because I had good care for all those years,” she said. “I experience more nerve pain now than ever before, and I still very much fear being cut off.
“God bless any doctor or human being who’s willing to support us during this terrible most tragic of times. We’re being put in a position to lose all semblance of pain management for good if this downward spiral is allowed to continue. That’s such an inhumane and ugly thing to do, after countless lovely vibrant lives have been snuffed out by the lack of it already. It’s my feeling we’ll look back on all this one day and realize this was in every aspect of the word a genocide; an attack on the weakest of us, the ones who most needed protection, but were mercilessly denied it.”
(PNN’s survey was conducted online and through social media from March 15 to April 17. A total of 4,185 people in the United States participated, including 3,926 who identified themselves as chronic, acute or intractable pain patients; 92 doctors or healthcare providers; and 167 people who said they were a caretaker, spouse, loved one or friend of a patient. Thanks to everyone who participated in this valuable survey. To see the full survey findings, click here.)
