Are You in Palliative or Curative Care?
/By Dr. Forest Tennant, PNN Columnist
If you are in medical treatment for a chronic disease, you are either in curative or palliative care. Every patient with intractable pain syndrome (IPS), their family and physicians need to be very clear as to which category they are in.
A major reason that IPS patients can’t get the help they need is because they have not made the determination and been declared to be in palliative care. If you are not in palliative care, you may be restricted from obtaining certain drugs, dosages and financial benefits you need for your well-being.
What is Curative Care?
Curative care is treatment that is focused on resolving a specific disease or disorder that is causing symptoms such as pain, fatigue, depression or physical impairments. Treatment can be directed either at total or partial cure of the disease or disorder.
What is Palliative Care?
Palliative care is symptomatic treatment to provide relief and quality of life to someone with an incurable condition. Palliative care will also hopefully prevent an incurable disease or disorder from worsening and causing further complications.
There are two reference books published for physicians so they can quickly look up the latest on diagnosis and treatment. Their definitions of palliative care are given here to help all parties know which care -- palliative or curative --- best fits any given patient.
“Palliative care is medical care focused on improving quality of life for people living with serious illness. Serious illness is defined as a condition that carries a high risk of mortality, negatively impacts quality of life and daily function and/or is burdensome in symptoms, treatments and caregiver stress.” -- Current Medical Diagnosis and Treatment
“Palliative care is treatment that is focused on pain and symptom management as well as quality of life for patients and their families. It can be rendered at any point in the course of treatment of illness, whether that illness is life threatening or not.” – Current Therapy
The World Health Organization defines palliative care as “prevention and relief of suffering in adults or pediatric patients and their families facing the problems associated with life-threatening illness.”
Misconceptions About Palliative Care
There are many misconceptions about what qualifies a patient to be palliative care. Here are just some of the common misconceptions and fallacies:
Must be at “end-of-life.” No! An incurable disease may occur at any age.
Must be in a hospice. No!
Must be on Medicare. No!
Must be in a nursing home, assisted living or hospital. No!
Must have cancer. No! Palliative care applies to any incurable disease.
Must enroll in a program called “palliative” or with a “palliative care organization.” No!
Must go to a doctor who specializes in palliative care. No!
Palliative care requires the patient to have a permit or certificate. No!
Even though there are some physicians and programs that specialize in palliative care, any MD or DO can declare a patient to be “palliative” and provide the necessary medication for relief of pain and other symptoms.
You may have to be declared to be in “palliative care” and have it stated in your medical record, so that you can obtain the medications and dosages to adequately relieve your pain. Federal guidelines specifically exempt palliative care patients from a recommendation that daily opioid doses not exceed 90 milligrams morphine equivalence (MME). If you have not been declared to be in palliative care and it isn’t in your medical record, your opioid dosage may be reduced.
Presenting Your Case for Palliative Care
In order to obtain proper care and necessary medications in today’s healthcare system, you will likely need to be declared “palliative” by one of your personal physicians. This declaration will need to be recorded in your medical record and all concerned parties informed of it. Your pharmacy, insurer, laboratory and other healthcare providers should all be told that you are in palliative care.
Most IPS patients need palliative care and meet the necessary requirements to be declared as palliative. One of your doctors needs to simply write into your medical record the name of your incurable disease, and that your treatment will focus on symptom management, comfort and quality of life. There is no requirement to state how long you may live.
The only required documentation is a written chart note in your medical record by a licensed physician in your state. They will need to state the specific name of your incurable disease and that you are in palliative care.
Every IPS patient and family needs to determine whether their treatment needs to be palliative or curative. While everyone would like a cure, this may not be practical or possible. What evidence or experience tells you that you can achieve a cure? It may be depressing to recognize that a complete cure is not possible, but you must face reality.
Keep in mind that an incurable disease and pain doesn’t have to keep you from having a meaningful, productive and good quality of life.
Forest Tennant, MD, DrPH, is retired from clinical practice but continues his research on intractable pain and arachnoiditis. This column is adapted from newsletters recently issued by the IPS Research and Education Project of the Tennant Foundation. Readers interested in subscribing to the newsletter can sign up by clicking here. The Tennant Foundation gives financial support to Pain News Network and sponsors PNN’s Patient Resources section.
