Rx Drug Databases Linked to Heroin Deaths

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

Prescription drug monitoring programs (PDMPs) in the U.S. are often promoted as critical tools in preventing opioid abuse and addiction. But a new study suggests that some PDMPs may be having the unintended effect of driving pain patients to street drugs such as heroin.

PDMPs in 49 states (the one exception is Missouri) allow physicians and pharmacists to consult a drug database to see if patients are “doctor shopping” or getting too many opioid prescriptions. The databases are also used by law enforcement agencies to identify doctors who prescribe high levels of opioid medication.  

A team of researchers reported in the International Journal of Drug Policy that there was a “consistent, positive, and significant association” between the adoption of PDMPs and fatal heroin overdoses. By the third year of a state adopting a PDMP, there was a 22% overall increase in heroin fatalities.

The increase was not uniform across all PDMPs.  States with “Proactive” PDMPs, which are more likely to flag suspicious activity by doctors and patients and report them to law enforcement, had a slight decline in heroin overdoses, while states with weaker PDMPs had significant increases in heroin deaths.

“The study just shows that heroin is an alternative to prescription pain medicine,” says John Lilly, DO, a Missouri physician who opposes PDMPs. “The harder it is to get prescription pain medicine, the more heroin deaths and presumably heroin use occurs. Market forces at work. Heroin is not the big alternative. It’s illicit fentanyl.”

It's not the first time researchers have found mixed results on the effectiveness of PDMPs. A 2018 study also found an increase in heroin deaths associated with PDMPs, along with a decline in overdoses linked to prescription opioids.

"It's pretty striking that this is the second study where we have found that PDMPs with robust features such as sending unsolicited alerts about outlying prescribing and dispensing patterns to PDMP users, and providing more open access to PDMP data, are associated with a small decline in opioid overdose deaths," said senior author Magdalena Cerdá, DrPH, an associate professor and director of the Center for Opioid Epidemiology and Policy at NYU Langone Health.

"In our prior study we found that these types of PDMPs were associated with a decline in prescription opioid overdose deaths, and this new study suggests Proactive PDMPs may also have a downstream protective effect on heroin overdose risk."

Cerdá and her colleagues believe PDMPs that aggressively flag and report suspicious activity will help stop inappropriate prescribing sooner and better identify patients in need of addiction treatment, preventing their transition to heroin. 

“To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to identify specific classes of PDMP characteristics that are most strongly associated with changes in rates of fatal heroin poisonings,” said lead author Silvia Martins, MD, an associate professor of epidemiology at Columbia Mailman School of Public Health. “We believe those authorized to access the data should be trained to protect individual privacy and confidentiality and ensure that it is used only to improve care for the patient.”

DEA Sues Colorado for Access to PDMP

Patient privacy is at issue in an unusual lawsuit filed last week by the Drug Enforcement Administration against Colorado’s Board of Pharmacy. The DEA subpoenaed the board to release patient data from Colorado’s PDMP to assist in the investigation of two pharmacies. But the state refused to comply, citing privacy concerns.

“The Department of Regulatory Agencies is committed to combating the opioid epidemic that remains a devastating issue for many Colorado communities,” spokeswoman Jillian Sarmo said in an email to the Colorado Sun. “We continue to work with our partners in other agencies in this fight, but we have an obligation to do so in a targeted and thoughtful manner that ensures the privacy of the hundreds of thousands of individual patients in the state whose personal prescription records have no connection to any criminal activity and whose disclosure has no relevance to any criminal investigation.”

Also named in the DEA lawsuit is Appriss, Inc., a private company that Colorado and dozens of other states use to collect and maintain their PDMP data. If a federal judge rules in favor of the DEA in Colorado, it could set a legal precedent that would force Appriss to release prescription data from other states.

“We are taking this action as part of our office’s efforts to aggressively pursue law enforcement investigations of anyone who may be breaking the law,” U.S. Attorney Jason Dunn said in a statement.  “We are disappointed with the refusal to comply with these lawful subpoenas, a refusal that has forced us to seek aid from the court in getting the information we need to carry out important law enforcement investigations aimed at combating the prescription drug abuse epidemic.” 

A recent study undermines much of the association between overdoses and prescription opioids that are obtained legally. Researchers say only 1.3% of overdose victims in Massachusetts had an active prescription for the opioid that killed them — meaning PDMPs would have little value in preventing the other 98.7% of deaths.