By Barby Ingle, PNN Columnist

Each year I get asked to support multiple legislative bills that could impact the chronic pain community. I look through them, think them through, and have written, called, testified and shared many over the years.

But sometimes a bill I supported comes back to haunt me as a patient. The intended consequences are not what I thought they would be.

Such is the case in Arizona, where I live. A state law was passed in 2013 calling for transparency in healthcare pricing (HB 2045). The law requires most healthcare providers to tell patients the “direct pay price” for a service or procedure. I always thought it was a good thing to have transparency in pricing and for patients to know what their responsibility is, so I supported the bill.

In 2019, Arizona passed another law (HB 2166) that authorized providers to collect “advance payments” from patients before a service is performed and without waiting for insurers to pay. The new law was quick to be adopted and providers have already started using it more than expected. This is causing an issue in getting the healthcare we need in a proper and timely manner.

The law really didn't affect me until this year, when I went through all the testing and multiple office visits with a new provider. Then I was called to the office of the “scheduling manager.” This was right after the doctor told me that I need a procedure on my bladder. I have an issue known as neurogenic bladder, where I lose control of my bladder nerves and muscles.

In the office, the woman wrote on a piece of paper the cost of the procedure ($30,000) based on my insurance (Medicare) and how much I would have to pay in advance, which was $6,000.

Before the law went into effect, I could pay the bill over time and get the procedure done when I needed it. But now, she says, I had to pay the entire $6,000 before even scheduling the procedure. I do not have $6,000 to pay upfront, so I am unable to schedule it.

New Hospital Rules

Arizona is not the only state that has passed healthcare price transparency laws; California, Connecticut, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Tennessee and Vermont have similar laws.

Federal rules are slated to go into effect in January, 2021 that will require hospitals to disclose their price information, including their negotiated prices with insurers. It is part of an effort by the Trump administration to increase price transparency in hopes of lowering healthcare costs on everything from hospital services to prescription medicines.

The federal efforts are controversial and have already faced court challenges. For good reason, seeing how transparency is being implemented in Arizona.  

Both HB 2045 and HB 2166 are good examples of bills I advocated for that are now being used against me and others in the chronic pain community who are low income or under-insured. It’s just a new way to stop healthcare or slow it down. Instead of having insurance companies delay care with prior authorizations and step therapy -- which I have been through as well -- they stop you at the doctor's office now.  

The same thing happened when I came down with Valley Fever pneumonia this past November. My provider ordered chest x-rays, but before I could get them, I had to pay my portion of the bill. I had to borrow money to get the x-rays done.  

Turns out I was way sicker than my provider thought and he apologized afterwards. Once I was diagnosed, follow up x-rays were covered, except when one lady was at the desk. She always charges me and says she has to because of the price transparency rules.  

I am hearing more and more stories about HB 2166 being used against the chronic and rare disease communities. As I said, it is odd to not want full transparency, but I would rather have access to healthcare when it is needed and then work on paying the bill afterward. Otherwise, like me, many of you may not receive the care you need, making our health worse and more expensive. 

Barby Ingle lives with reflex sympathetic dystrophy (RSD), migralepsy and endometriosis. Barby is a chronic pain educator, patient advocate, and president of the International Pain Foundation. She is also a motivational speaker and best-selling author on pain topics. More information about Barby can be found at her website.